Toll Collecting

Michael Froomkin’s musing that toll collector might be the worst job has lead to some to be less than amused but, yeah; I was amused for the self centered reason that I’ve thought a lot about toll collecting. You see my favorite business model is the two sided network, i.e. a hub that coordinates the transaction traffic between two groups and for the longest time my preferred visualization for this model is as a bridge between the two populations.  The toll taking funds the owner’s house on the beach.  These are very profitable businesses that are very hard to create. They are like the old and foolish idea of selling to China where in you fantasize making a vast sum of money by charging a vast population a tiny tiny amount of money. Businesses like this are easy to find, because they have to touch vast populations, but they are very hard to build because you have to coordinate the millions, or billions, of transactions. Not just get those transactions to take place, you have to charge a toll on each one.

I love the saying the economics takes as it’s area of interest solved political problems, e.g. that each simple economic transaction marks a solution to some political problem. Of course every transaction is a political act. My choice where to buy Harry Potter is a vote in a political negotiation about the nature of modern retailing; the currency system I use, the store I select, the discounts (bribes) I garner, etc. etc. all fold into that politics. I suspect, for example, that the average cost to merchants of credit card transactions is around 5-7% of the transaction. Contrasting that to the total tax burden it seems like a very high cost for an alternate currency system. The regulatory framework around that, for example the bankruptcy rules, are of course a part of negotiating those taxes; a political problem. We have, depending upon our mood, various names for the processes that frame the politics of these negotiations about how to coordinate the transactions and who gets to collect the tolls if any. We can call it creative destruction, entrepreneurship, institution building, politics, revolution, etc. etc.

Sometimes we even call it freedom not so much because each time you succeed in creating a new high volume widely used from of exchange you create a bloom of new options for fun things in it’s penumbra; but because often the new institutional framework routes around an existing system’s constraints. It maybe the relaxing of constraints that creates the sense of freedom more than the bloom of fresh options. (I think there is something in that which is related to Clay’s recent point about “taking for granted“; e.g. that those freed have a hard time taking full advantage of the fresh option space because their muscles are somehow stiff; but I’m not clear exactly what.)

In the folk tale I recall the ferryman tricks one of his passengers into taking over his job. I have a few fluffy theories as to why that is. The toll collector is not the owner of the hub; he’s just a cog in the machine. In fact the hub owner would prefer that he never gum up the works. Heaven forbid that he should enter add complexity to the transaction. The toll taking is added complexity already the owner would prefer that tax be as invisible as possible.

There are two other reasons though; that extend beyond just the toll taker and effect the hub owner. The owner of a successful hub has a captured something of a monopoly; what a military man might call a high value target. Keeping everything running smoothly is tough work. Meanwhile each of those travelers passing over the ferry are going someplace, doing something, they are on holiday, going to town, moving on. They are free. He is not; he’s got a job to do.

Delegating to the toll booth collector the tedium is all well and good; but after a bit the toll booth collector has the worst of all perspectives. He sits in the center of a monopoly touching each coin of the monopoly rents but keeping none of it while watching all the happy travelers exercising the options created enabled by the solution to the coordination problem in which he can not share. No wonder, after a while, the begins to fantasize trading places with one of the travelers.

Delightfully, in the folktale the ferryman finally manages to foist the gig off on the king.

Bill starts a dating service

I had the fun a long time ago of being the first bidder on this auction:

Today Bill told a bit more of the story.

See, something else happened: During the sale dozens of people contacted me by email and telephone. They weren’t seeing it as a joke. They were anxious to bid. They regretted being unable to participate. The wanted to work with me on research, or with anybody on research, or have a chance to carry forward research they had started but lost.

They wanted to collaborate.

They were graduate students, and laymen, and people with Ph.D.s and M.S. and other advanced degrees in mathematics and science and engineering and humanities and social sciences and art. And they were busy, and focused, and full of ideas and every one felt disenfranchised.

For one reason or another they felt unable to collaborate in serious research, to follow ideas through to completion with colleagues. They were stymied by sexism (MIT-trained female math Ph.D., forced into industry by uncollaborative peers), by the burden of diligence (graduate and undergraduate students, or industrial researchers ordered to focus and pay attention on their immediate work), by the walls of the many-siloed Ivory Tower itself. Or they were smart academics in the right position, who had nobody willing to collaborate with them in a culture that over-values competition and secrecy and primary authorship. Some were full professors, fully-credentialled but held back by service or administrative obligations, or funding hardships, or some other oft-voiced complaint. Some were in small ivy-covered undergraduate teaching institutions, or community colleges, and just out of luck for chances to do some work.

Nobody seemed dumb. Nobody sounded like they were trying to scam a lightened workload by foisting the hard part of their project over to me. Nobody was trying to cheat on their homework or thesis. Nobody was a creationist, nobody was astroturfing. They all made it sound as if finding a colleague was the best thing they could imagine.

I make it out to be very general, very broad, almost ubiquitous. There was diversity in the character of response, but I’m not exaggerating: nearly two dozen people contacted me. This expression of disenfranchisement was a shared trait of a stream of email correspondents, and people who called me directly on my business line. They didn’t really care how good or bad I was, and maybe didn’t care too much about my credentials. The fact that I seemed capable, and serious, and willing to give my time and energy to thinking and talking with them about something they were interested in that was enough.

I have a catalog of insta-theories for Open Source, but that there is always a kind of desperate undercurrent of demand for quality collaborators isn’t in that catalog. I’ll go fix that.

Wegman’s

One of the institutions of upstate New York is Wegman’s, here in Ithaca the Wegman’s is a vast box store; i.e. the size of a Walmart or a Target.  It makes you wish you had a bicycle.  Like other modern grocery retailing machines they try to lock you in with a loyality card.  I have a small collection of these for the stores around Boston, all in Mr. Gate’s name, so you can imagine my disappointment that Wegman’s actually requires you to show your driver’s license before they issue one.

Reading as I am regional histories has brought to my attention that the US suffered a major economic Panic in 1837.  One event in that unfolding mess was the point when banks, which at the time issued most of the folding money, all stopped exchanging it for hard currency.      “Out of 850 banks in the United States, 343 closed entirely, sixty-two failed partially, and the system of State banks received a shock from which it never fully recovered.”  The customers of those banks and the holders of their currency lost everything.  They were locked-in, what a marketing person would call loyal.  How money should work became a key issue in the national debate for a long period following.  Over time the US moved from a highly distributed currency system to a centralized one.  I believe we are moving back to something more privately run.  The loyalty cards only a small part of that.
Once in possession of your Wegman’s loyalty card the check out transaction process has three steps.  First you prove you are a loyal members of the Wegman’s club by swiping your card.  At that point you are presented with a screen with, and this is the amazing part, 8 choices on it!  These distinguish which currency system you want to use.  Having selected, for example credit, you then swipe a second card to reveal what credit card network your allied with.  There is a fourth step where you sign the receipt; but this is optional based on rules I haven’t investigated.

The reason for all these currency systems is to allow thier operators to take slice of every transaction.  The slices are huge, many percent.  A huge operator like Wegman’s probably has the slice negotated down; but a small retailer, like the coop in Ithaca (who also has a loyality program), is probably paying 5-7% across all his transactions.  Meanwhile I got a 2$ off the price of a pie.

Of course the faux reason for these systems is efficiency.    Here’s a lovely blog posting about that!, where in the writer attempts to fight back because he’s so peeved by the Visa Ad campaign intended to shame people who aren’t getting with the program.

As an interesting complement to all this the Ithaca community has a long running experiment in trying to run it’s own currency system.  I presume they are called Ithaca Hours to link them to work rather than gold.  In the period following the Panic of 1837 many companies started paying their workers in scrip.  I love the idea of local currencies, but I must admit I can’t quite puzzle out if they are a good or a bad witch.  I am confident that the entire credit card/debit-card system ought to be run by the US treasury; the cost of running these alternate currency systems is outrageous.

City

I’ve thought and read about cities for decades so it is extremely cool to encounter a new idea.  I’m currently on vacation in Ithaca NY, and before hand I wandered into the Architecture library at work to pick up a book about the Finger Lakes region.    That book was a disappointment, but nearby was a big thick book confidently called City about New Haven Connecticut and as is my wont I picked it up too.  City: Urbanism and Its End by Douglas Rae adds two new, to me, pieces to the puzzle of what happened to the American cities.

My father used to tell a story about a scholarly study of what climate is most suited to civilization.  The scholars plotted latitude of the great civilizations down through the ages.  Fitting a curve to their data they showed conclusively that the current optimal location of a civilization was New Haven Connecticut.  Needless to say the scholars were at Yale.  I grabbed the book in the hope it would turn out my father’s story wasn’t entirely tongue and cheek.

Geography does shape civilizations of course.  The presumption that Yankee thrift and innovation is a consequence of the Puritan culture, to take a common example, is thrown into question by the story of how the Puritans who migrated to Central America at the same time  ended up being slave owning oligarchs.  In that case the distinguishing factor appears to be labor availability.  In New England labor was dear, land wasn’t; while in the Central America it was the other way around.  Dear and innovation go hand and hand.

The thesis of “City: Urbanism and Its End,” beautifully and delicately presented in the first chapter, states that cities, like New Haven, made sense as a coordinating device only for a short period, less than a century.  It’s conventional to say that the automobile killed the center cities and in models of that kind the primary driver of how concentrated our settlements are is the transportation system used to glue them together.  Old cities in Italy have narrow streets because they were used on foot while modern urban spaces care more about tractor-trailers than tricycles.

The usual complement to the transportation based models of city concentration are ones about endowment.  First there were the natural endowments, a good and defensible harbor or along an existing trade route for example early London or New York’s are examples of that.    Later cities became their own endowment; aggregating social networks, capital, functional governance, etc. etc.  San Jose, and Silicon Value, is a modern example and Venice or Amsterdam a older one.  This model of cities as aggregating increasing returns in their endowments is my preferred model for what shapes the concentration of populations into cities; in part because it seems to fit well the power-law distribution of city sizes.

In the years prior to the rise of cities like New Haven the population was concentrating into what he calls Fall Line Cities, i.e. cities build along a river that was rapidly descending so as to take advantage of water power.  Labor, capital, expertise, the whole complex knot needed to make industrialism work, had to migrated to the power source.  That changed with the advent of steam power, railroads, coal, etc.

So that’s new to me.  Energy was no longer dear, or at least no longer immovable,it could no longer command all the other elements of the party to show up where ever it happened to be.  Once energy stopped being the key endowment other factors became the hard thing coordinate.  The city became the party.  One consequence of that insight is to wake up to the key role that electricity plays in blowing apart the 20th century central city.  It is, possibly, just a critical to the story as the automobile.  Before electricity you wanted to be near a rail or flat water to get your coal, to run your steam engines.  This reminded me of another of my father’s stories.  He had a friend who started a company making fiber optics, and that factory was carefully sited to be adjacent to a high tension power line near a small New England town with a concentration of optics expertise.

But there is yet another part to the story that is new to me.  Some years ago I was shocked to watch how real estate interests in Massachusetts were able to override the governance of the states principle cities using a statewide proposition.  Rae highlights how cities are seriously handicapped in the US by how their governance is structured.  In 1907 the Supreme Court wrote: “The State .. at its pleasure may modify or withdraw all [city] powers, may take without compensation [city] property, hold it itself, or vest it in other agencies, expand or contract the territorial area, unit the whole or a part of it with another municipality, repeal the charter and destroy the corporation.  All this maybe done, conditionally or unconditionally, with or without the consent o the citizens, or even against their protest.  In all these respects the State is supreme.”

That’s why, for example, suburban and rural voters could pass a referendum over the objections of city dwellers in Massachusetts.  That’s why New York city can’t get it’s hands on a half a Billion dollars from the feds for congestion pricing without sharing a large portion of the money with the rest of New York state.  Why New York is attacked by terrorists and we send money not to cities but to states where it buys toys for rural police departments rather than improved harbor security.  It’s why when the automobile began to undermine the numerous endowments that cities has accumulated they had such a hard time fighting back; and it goes a long way toward explaining why European cities were more successful in tempering the displacement of those endowments.

Of all the endowments cities have the diversity and richness their social and knowledge networks are the ones I find most fascinating.  My father’s friend needed electricity and a pool of optics expertise he could draw upon.  I’ve thought that eBay and Google couldn’t have happened in any other situation; they desperately needed the pool of expertise that only the bay area could provide.  These endowments are the ones that Jane Jacob’s emphasises in her works.  By the time she was writing cities were created innovation but as firms grew they threw their factories out into the periphery.  Just as Apple manufactures in Taiwan, or Google puts it’s servers next to hydroelectric plants.  It is, just possible, that the Internet will displace these social/knowledge endowment as well.  While I don’t know how that will play out for cities what I do know is that it’s harder than it looks replicating those in on the fabric provided by the net.

Fridge advice?

Here’s a shout out. Our fridge is misbehaving. It’s an Amana, with the freezer on the bottom. The freezer is working fine. The top has stopped working. Anybody got a theory on how that’s possible?

Update: I took it apart. There is a fan in the bottom freezer that circulates cold air. Included in that circulation is the run of air that chills the upper part. The fan isn’t working. I removed it and tested it. Of course it worked; but it also behaves in a manner that suggests it’s variable speed and has a thermostat. So I suspect I need to replace it. I put it all back together and it worked until we finished cleaning it; then it stopped.

Update 2: Disassembled again, the bearing in the fan motor is worn out. Once you know this thing is called an evaporator fan you can find some pretty good sites showing how the fridge is put together. More delightfully I found pdf containing a scan of the typewritten paper outlining the design. It was written in 1978 by some engineers at Amana in Iowa and the work was funded by the US government in service of making appliances more efficient. It looks to me like the design is unchanged in almost 30 years. Now to find the part, locally, on a Saturday.

Update 3: New fan: $80.  Installed, everything works – yeah. Oh boy, it’s really quiet!  20 minutes later it stops – boo.  A while later – it works – yeah?  24 hours later it all seems pretty good; and i think the random stopping is part of a defrost cycle.  Reading what I refer to as my handbook for obsessive compulsives I learn that the freezer should be around zero degree’s F, and the upper part should be around 36 degrees.  So far I’ve managed to get the top right, and the bottom’s 10 degrees too cold.  It’s now clear we should have sensed trouble when: it got noisy, the beer started getting warm, and the lettuce started freezing.

Bus Driver’s guide to Project Management

I take the bus to work most every day and recently I’ve noticed two new, to me, syndromes.  First off I’ve noticed that I catch later of two morning buses it will passes the earlier bus on it’s way.  Secondly I’ve noticed  that if the bus is even a few seconds ahead of schedule this advantage will  accumulate so that it arives at the train station quite a bit ahead of schedule. Both of these have to do with passenger loading delays.

The 2nd bus wins because it is less popular, so it stops less often; while the 1st bus is very popular and has to stop a lot.  It’s the passengers,  and their loading time.

The second syndrome, where the amount a bus is running ahead of schedule piles up is also due to the passengers.  In this case the bus doesn’t have to pickup passengers who come out to the bus stop on schedule.  I’ve noticed that when I miss my favorite bus, but I’m on schedule, it will drive by empty – which of of course get’s my goat.

These are interesting complementary syndromes and they suggest that being on schedule is unstable.  Early buses tend to become even earlier, since the load they usually carry doesn’t appear; while buses that run late tend to accumulate additional loading costs.  It’s fun to think about how one might overlay some regulatory scheme to temper these effects.

Seems to me there is an analagous syndrome in projects.  Delayed projects tend to accumulate more items, as the delays allow more requirements to show up and pile-on.  Projects ahead of schedule tend to pick up speed as they drive pass additional requirements which haven’t managed to get the meetings on time.

It’s interesting to muse about what interventions one might take in these situations.  Driving by a few bus stops to get back on schedule, or explicitly ignoring a few project requriments is very hard to execute on.  There is one bus driver on my route who appears to have discovered that he can spend a lot more time drinking coffee if he gets ahead of schedule; the man’s a maniac.  I’ve worked with managers like that.

The Road Less Traveled

I’ve read that given two stores people will tend to visit the one that is toward the city center in preference to the one that’s in the other direction.  It’s as if you had to climb uphill to move away from the city center.  Customers tend to flow, like water toward the commercial centers.

These effects get filled under the term Hoteling in some of the economics’s literature.  In it’s most naive form Hoteling is kind of stupid; it merely points out that buyers include the total cost of a transaction when making a purchase.  The vegetables maybe spectacular at Russo’s or dirt cheap at Haymarket; both a half hour round trip from my house; but the Foodmaster  at the bottom of my street is a damn sight more convenient.  Which goes to explain why there are a few dozen Foodmaster’s around town; like a hotel chain Mr. Foodmaster knows that part of what he’s selling is being close at hand.

My reading on hyperbolic discounting suggests that hoteling effects are much stronger than mere arithmetic would suggest.  I suspect that people have extremely skewed models about this stuff.  The hills are much steeper than it’s possible to imagine.  That most people shop closer to home and stick to the main roads far more than would be in their best interest.

I’ve always been a road less traveled kind of guy.  As a child, before first grade, I can recall lying in bed tracing out the roads of my town; wondering what was down particular turns my parents had never taken.  As an adult I have a self amused tendency to take turns out of raw curiosity and a strong preference for taking the roads the super highways replaced.  I know that the interesting authentic vendors tend to be hidden, around the corner, up the stairs, where their unique qualities sustain them; rather than their proximity to traffic.

Hoteling effects, of course, take place in your mind too.  When something new needs an explanation you fall naturally into the existing explanations.  When you must decide what to do your thoughts flow into existing channels.  It would be, it is, exhausting not to.

In this country, where we have traditionally had tremendous amounts of empty real estate, we have undergone waves of upheaval that have transformed the shape of the traffic flows.  We have successively overlaid networks of rivers, turnpikes, canals, railroads, and superhighways.  For better or worse, each time these have created new commercial centers while displacing older ones.

In each round some people got really rich.  Not by buying the land cheap and selling it high, but by shaping the traffic flows until they came to the land they owned.    Some railroad barons are and were more conscious of this process than others.  For example the folks building Facebook are clearly working hard to see that social traffic flows over their turnpikes.

As a guy who like to take the road less traveled I’m pleased to see that Google Maps has added little handles to their suggested routes that enable me to dynamically drag them.  Now I can insist that, yes I do want to drive thru downtown on this trip; and yes I do want to make detour that goes along the beach road, and yes I do want to cross the river on that exceptionally narrow bridge.  But I wonder, why did they decide that such a feature would actually be interesting to most people?  Most people aren’t like me.  I suspect I’m way out on the long tail of map users; but then I suspect the folks working on Google maps are too.

Craft v.s. Art.

This is a very elegantly written posting.

Most people are not aware of the depths of the argument that between the fine craft establishment and the dominate fine art elite.  I used to think about that debate more; but I’m pleased to note something about it.

Fine art is at it’s core about scarcity; fine craft is much less so; and what has come to be called crafting hardly at all.  The fine craft movement, which weaves it’s way back through all of history and all nations, in it’s modern manifestation, I’m surprised to note, a lot like open source.

I hate to play that card.  The term open source has almost fallen dead for me.  So many people play that card in an attempt to grab a bit of legitimacy for what every scheme they are executing that involves sucking talent out of the vast pool of people on the other side of the internet; and don’t get me started on the neologism ‘democratizing.’

What is going on in the modern crafting movement, as manifested in the web, is the thing I think is coolest about the Internet.  First off it has a pool of people of common interest finding each other, like a giant pot luck dinner or a stone soup.  They are creating energy and knowledge that wasn’t there before; in an commons.  Secondly the energy of this movement comes from the periphery; the respect of the participants faces toward the periphery.

When this works you get the opposite of scarcity based activities.  In fine arts the entire community is polarized by the pervasive question of who’s at the top, who can command the premium prices, who’s hot, who’s not.  In a periphery facing community the tension, the anxiety if you wish, is where on the vast periphery the next insight will emerge, the next cool trick of the trade, the next breath taking bit of design.